J.E.Mosel
  • Home
  • Gallery
  • Illustration
  • Sketches
  • Writing
  • Thoughts & News
  • Contact
  • Photos
  • Illustrations in Progress
  • Earth Ride (The Pipeline Blog)

Understanding

1/6/2011

2 Comments

 
Today I encountered a disheartening opinion. It begins with a topic which has grown in frustration for me, before turning to the disheartening matter itself. Speaking with a fellow student worker, the subject came up that I do not eat meat. I was asked why (as usual). Personally, I have a number of reasons, which I grow tired of defending. I do not ask those who consume meat the reasons for that decision, or to justify themselves -- despite the fact that the consumption of meat is in fact far more unsustainable and in any case, it is worthwhile no matter what you eat to understand why you do so. Yet I find continuously that I must justify myself. My honest response in these cases would be that I feel I should not need to justify myself. I have made a decision, one that was guided by deep thought and consideration regarding all the advantages and disadvantages. It is a decision that I stand by. Thus, I fail to see how it is acceptable to ask me, as a vegetarian, why I do not eat meat, when at the same time it is unacceptable, even intrusive, to ask a smoker why they smoke -- regardless that the smoker harms themselves, and those around them. Meanwhile, I am making a conscious, educated decision to go without a foodstuff that is for me unnecessary, and come to judgment.

That answer, of course, is not the one I provide in response to inquiry. Although I find it irritating, the inevitable response of 'why?' 'how come?' or 'what made you decide that?' to the devulging of my eating preferences, -- that is, when I am cast beneath a disapproving eye for such a decision -- I do not begrudge those who ask with genuine curiosity; I am happy to answer their questions. And to them, I say this. Firstly, meat is not a necessary part of my common diet. In other words, I can find other sources of protein, iron, and other nutrients. When I was younger, I never sought meat overmuch, and so found it natural to quit it as I came under control of my own. Certainly, meat is a powerful energy source, and one that can be useful to the human diet. I would be a fool to say otherwise. It has its uses, and there are undoubtedly people for whom it is advisable to consume. But for me personally, it is not the only option. Not eating meat means that I must be conscious of my choices, and insure that I am consuming all that my body needs to function well, and healthily without meat, yet so long as I am capable I choose to go without it. Secondly, it is not environmentally sound, or morally sound, for me to continue consuming something that I do not need, and that is not sustainable. Methane emissions from beef production -- and dairy -- as well as the negative impacts of massive numbers livestock  for other meats (pigs, fowl, etc.) are a serious problem facing our future, and I do not wish to contribute to that demand. That being said, if all meat was hunted sustainably, if meat was produced locally at small scales, and garnered in a manner that was uncruel and used responsibly, I would find it difficult to object to meat consumption. Moderation is key. After all, carnivorousness is a common strategy for other animals. Yet the fact remains: for those animals, there is no other option -- the wolf's strategy in life requires prey; my strategy in life does not. It may be time to pose the question instead 'why do you eat meat?' I know my reasons; do you know yours?

And now we approach the disheartening matter itself. Many have contended my environmental reasons for not eating meat; often the argument's of my opponents are ones that I have considered, myself. The production of soybeans, for example, is just as environmentally irresponsible as meat when performed on a large scale monoculture, with herbicides and pesticides, yet is a staple for many vegetarians. However, you cannot replace meat solely by tofu, and secondly, here again I call upon moderation. Replacing meat with tofu is not a solution, and should not be used to contend me. Today, my fellow student worker disagreed with my environmental motivations, but I was dismayed to learn that it was not for the reason I anticipated. Apparently, climate change is a farce -- a scheme whereby environmentalists aim to make a profit. Clearly, he told me when I objected, Al Gore is making millions from the endeavor. Al Gore aside, it has been a long time since I encountered such an opinion. I had hoped that, at a place of learning, my fellow students would take it upon themselves to investigate the truth of all matters. If this student had done so, he would quickly learn that, for those truly concerned for our world, a personal profit should be far from their goals. This is indeed the case. To be dirt poor, and yet see the environmental soundness of this planet, I would be forever content. Climate change is a very real thing, and although there have been natural fluctuations in the history of the planet, it is undeniable that this change in atmospheric composition stems from our industrial activity. I had no other answer to him, other than this: seek truths, before you accept heresay. See for yourself, and the truth is obvious. I have done the research, I have seen -- and participated -- in the science. But you do not need to be a scientist to read a graph, nor to understand that, climate change or not, our society is unsustainable and ultimately damaging. A change must be made. Fossil fuels are not the option, and we must take responsibility, however challenging, frightening, or uncomfortable the weight of that responsibility may be. Delude yourself at the expense of yourself, not at the expense of the planet.
2 Comments
De Pere SEO link
10/5/2012 11:43:16 am

I thoroughly enjoyed this blog and created a Weebly account too.

Reply
Bonnie West
12/28/2012 03:07:06 am

I love your thoughts on this. I am enjoying this entire blog..and now just going back to the beginning... Thanks for writing it. You are so thoughtful... You have no need to justify your behavior. I am surprised when so very many people have chosen to be vegetarians or vegans that anyone even asks you. !! Hope you are still happy in Japan. Diane and I enjoy following your adventures...and of course the illustrations are wonderful!!! Bonnie

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture
    Picture
    Thoughts, musings, updates about your's truly, and what I am up to.

    Archives

    August 2019
    February 2019
    July 2018
    March 2018
    March 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    February 2016
    July 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    June 2014
    February 2014
    October 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    May 2012
    September 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010

    Categories

    All
    Ainu
    Art
    Art Festival
    Australia
    Bees
    Bike Trip
    Biking
    Biomass
    Chiang Mai
    Chippewa National Forest
    Climate Change
    Corvallis Fall Festival
    Daily Life
    Distance Running
    Drought
    Earthride
    Ecophysiology
    Education
    Environment
    Equality
    Feminism
    Forest
    Forest Management
    Fulbright
    Graduate School
    Hiking
    History
    Hokkaido
    Japan
    Kindness
    Kyoto
    Lake Harriet
    Mac 50k
    Marathon
    McDonald Forest
    Minnehaha
    Minnesota
    Morioka
    Native
    Nature
    New Zealand
    Oregon
    Oregon State University
    Paintings
    PhD
    Plants
    Politics
    Quotes
    Research
    Rights
    Running
    Sappachi
    Sapporo
    Science
    Shiretoko
    Silviculture
    Sister
    Spring
    State Park
    St. Olaf
    Summer
    Thailand
    Tokyo
    Track
    Trail Running
    Travel
    Tree Climbing
    Trees
    Trump
    Tsukuba
    Ultra-marathon
    United States
    Walk
    Winter
    Writing

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.